Did you feel sorry for Scourge at the beginning of TRoS?
Reviere | 2008-07-01 21:34 | Haven't read it yet Thank
Haven't read it yet
Thank you Riskay, Thank you, Thank you!
login or register to post comments
Rubykit | 2008-07-01 22:04 | I didn't feel bad, but I
I didn't feel bad, but I love/d Scourgey! If you want to know why I didn't feel really feel bad, check here: http://wandsandworlds.com/community/node/4921.
Anyway, I voted "yes". :)
![](http://i271.photobucket.com/albums/jj160/mollydogitadog/Siggies/WelcometoBloodClanfinalcopy-2.jpg?t=1214619025")
©Ruby. Scourgey...! <3
login or register to post comments
Swiftstep | 2008-07-01 23:12 | I haven't read it... Visit
I haven't read it...
Visit Swiftstep's Lair!
login or register to post comments
Waterstripe | 2008-07-02 00:19 | I don't feel bad for cats or
I don't feel bad for cats or people who get their feelings hurt or have bad lives because that's what makes a good book. You have to have something to drive a character.
I love K.C./The Veronicas/C.U./L.L./J.S.
Status: Reading Ender's Shadow, and rocking out to my music!
crescentmoon | 2008-07-02 09:47 | Ruby: Something's wrong
Ruby: Something's wrong here. You didn't feel bad but you voted yes?
I will read it in the next few days. Been way too sleepy lately to read anything after dinner (& before dinner, I'm not home).
Crescentmoon, techno-weenie
"Do I look like an out-of-bounds sort of guy?"
Capt. Jack Harkness, Dr. Who
Jaypaw X the Stick of Wonder!!
BOOK STATUS: I've read Warrior's Return. Half way through Outcast.
login or register to post comments
Losty | 2008-07-02 10:54 | Yes, I really did ^^ Plus, I
Yes, I really did ^^
Plus, I admire him! The forest Clans are beginning to really irk me. Something about them... I dunno, they just tick me off.
Losty~
"Our time has run out, our future has died - there's no more escape!
Now the day has come - we are forsaken...
Today is the end of tomorrow..."
-'Forsaken' by Within Temptation
Please click =)
login or register to post comments
Hazelleaf | 2008-07-02 12:58 | He's so pathetic at the begginning!He's unwanted and loved least
no wonder he went nuts!
~Hazelleaf of RiverClan~
a light ginger tabby with blue eyes
login or register to post comments
Rubykit | 2008-07-02 17:32 | Cmoon: Well, I didn't think
Cmoon: Well, I didn't think his past was very traumatizing. I wanted something really bad. I won't post spoilers or anything, but I was very disappointed by the story. And... *no one kill me here* but I wasn't going to vote "No" just because he knocked off one of Firestar's lives. XP
Losty: Yeah, city cats are cool! Lol.
©Ruby. Scourgey...! <3
login or register to post comments
Losty | 2008-07-02 18:35 | Lol, yeah, I wish he woulda
Lol, yeah, I wish he woulda got all of 'em like he did to Tigerstar lol
And YAY city cats! Woot-woot! =D
Losty
"Our time has run out, our future has died - there's no more escape!
Now the day has come - we are forsaken..."
-'Forsaken' by Within Temptation
login or register to post comments
crescentmoon | 2008-07-04 19:41 | SPOILER!!!!!!
Now that I've read the book, I say yes. I felt so sad for Tiny. It broke my heart when he said "Good-bye Mama" & left because he thought he'd be thrown in the river. His brother & sister were evil. He should have been able to stay home where he was safe with his mother.
Ruby: I absolutely agree about the story!
Vicky didn't convince me that his experiences were bad enough to make him a cold-blooded killer. It just didn't follow, even though he wanted revenge on Tigerstar & wanted to show his brother & sister he was strong. I could see how he would be bitter, but not as evil as he was in TDH.
And Tigerstar sure looked moth-eaten. And who is on the sump just before the battle in the forest? The way the manga went didn't match the real story. It was like he went to the forest & attacked Tigerstar before ever meeting any of the other clans. Well, I wonder what will be in the other 2 Scourge books.
Crescentmoon, techno-weenie
"Do I look like an out-of-bounds sort of guy?"
Capt. Jack Harkness, Dr. Who
Jaypaw X the Stick of Wonder!!
BOOK STATUS: I've read Warrior's Return. Half way through Outcast.
login or register to post comments
Losty | 2008-07-04 20:31 | There's not going to be
There's not going to be anymore Scourge books =(
Losty
"Our time has run out, our future has died - there's no more escape!
Now the day has come - we are forsaken..."
-'Forsaken' by Within Temptation
login or register to post comments
Sparrowheart | 2008-07-19 18:34 | I voted yes. I was so sorry
I voted yes. I was so sorry for him, and now I can't think of him as an evil homicidal cat. I curse his brother and sister because they were so mean to him. And then he turned evil. There. You have it.
LONG LIVE THE SQUIRRELS!!!!
login or register to post comments
Sparrowheart | 2008-08-25 16:30 | Even though I was rather
Even though I was rather bored with the plot...I really skimmed through the book.
Click Vipa!
Click Meh!
Click Meh!
Click Meh!
login or register to post comments
